Reimagining narratives: individualism to collectivism

November 4, 2024

AI generated text about a possible future of media and narratives

Reimagining Popular Narratives: From Individualism to Collective Growth

In the current era of popular culture, particularly in the realm of rap music, there seems to be an obsession with sex, materialism, and individual success. The dominant narratives revolve around images of luxury cars, stacks of money, and prestigious clothing brands—a kind of materialistic heaven that represents the ultimate goal. However, what if the future of media shifts its focus from these end results to the actual journey and struggle of life itself?

There is an opportunity to explore characters who embody both the challenges and triumphs of the human experience, rather than solely depicting the final destination of success. This shift could move us away from the current emphasis on selfishness, narcissism, and solipsism, which is often encouraged by consumerist culture. While individuality is important, and we all must navigate our own paths, there is a risk of these narratives going too far and neglecting the power of collective action and growth.

Narratives of Collaboration and Shared Purpose

Television shows like Stranger Things offer a glimpse into the potential of stories that showcase people working together, each contributing their unique skills to overcome a shared obstacle. However, the oppositional nature of the show's premise, with its focus on defeating evil monsters, may not be the ideal model for the types of narratives we need. On the other hand, games like Animal Crossing represent the opposite extreme, where the challenges are so mundane and the environment so pleasant that it may lack the necessary tension to drive compelling narratives.

Instead, we can look to examples like the movie The Martian, where the protagonist's individual struggle is deeply intertwined with the collective efforts of his team on Earth. The film portrays a balance between personal challenges and the importance of collaboration, as the entire world comes together to support the stranded astronaut. These narratives could shift further to emphasize the collective journey, where the success of the protagonist is directly tied to the betterment of their community or even humanity as a whole.

Everyday Struggles and Triumphs

The question then becomes, what can be dramatic and engaging without relying on the presence of an ultimate evil? The sitcom Seinfeld provides one answer, with its focus on the everyday annoyances and absurdities of life, and how its characters navigate and often contribute to these situations. However, the show's creators intentionally avoided character growth and development, opting for a more static, episodic format. This static approach, while comedic, also highlights how stories can be engaging without dramatic stakes. But what happens if we explore growth in such environments?

Shows like Parks and Recreation provide examples of how we can explore growth within a mundane framework. It offers a mix of personal development and group achievement, where characters work toward goals that affect their communities. The show emphasizes collaboration, civic duty, and overcoming bureaucratic challenges, demonstrating that small wins in everyday life can be compelling and inspirational.

The Possibilities of Collective Growth

Is it possible to create a story that combines the best elements of these examples—one that is group-oriented, focused on collective growth rather than individual arcs, and tackles the challenges of everyday life without relying on a dramatic, evil force? A narrative that is mundane yet difficult, real yet aspirational, and ultimately imparts wisdom and guidance for personal and societal betterment?

What if, instead of focusing on a singular "hero's journey," the media began portraying the collective journey of a group—whether a family, friends, or colleagues—who evolve together and confront the challenges of life? The workplace drama The Office already hints at this, blending individual character arcs with collective challenges, where the stakes aren't life-or-death but rather about learning to work together despite differences.

The TV show Community is another example that embodies the idea of a group working together and growing collectively. The series follows a study group at a community college, each member with their own quirks, flaws, and personal struggles. While the show is primarily a comedy, it also delves into the characters' individual growth and how they learn to support one another. The group faces various challenges, from school projects to personal conflicts, and they often find that their success depends on their ability to work together and leverage each other's strengths. Through their shared experiences, they not only achieve their academic goals but also develop deep, meaningful relationships and become better versions of themselves. Community demonstrates how a diverse group of people can come together, overcome their differences, and grow collectively through shared struggles and triumphs.

In a world where global problems like climate change, wealth inequality, and social justice are interconnected, the most powerful narratives may emerge from groups working toward a common goal. Stories could focus on addressing these real-world issues within communities, such as narratives about teams of scientists tackling climate change, educators reforming failing schools, or even everyday citizens banding together to protect local wildlife or natural resources.

Rethinking Success: The Collective Outcome

Another potential example comes from popular documentaries like The Biggest Little Farm, which follows a couple trying to build a sustainable farm that works in harmony with nature. The story is both personal and collective as they learn to manage the land with the help of animals, soil, plants, and people. The farm’s eventual success is a collective triumph—a microcosm of how community and environment can prosper together.

Perhaps the stories we need are those that depict the development of a group, working together to navigate the complexities of life and striving to become more mature, whole individuals who have the capacity to improve the world for others, for animals, and for future generations. By shifting our focus from individual success and materialism to collective growth and the betterment of all, we can create narratives that inspire and guide us toward a more compassionate, sustainable future.

Expanding on What’s Possible: Beyond Existing Formats

Taking this a step further, we might reimagine media that incorporates interactive elements. Games like Journey emphasize cooperative play between strangers, fostering a sense of collective achievement with minimal focus on individual accolades. We can imagine this same kind of collaborative storytelling being brought into other formats, like reality TV or interactive documentaries, where the emphasis is not on winning or achieving personal fame, but on how participants can build something meaningful together.

Ultimately, our media could evolve to reflect the changing values of society—a move away from hyper-individualism toward narratives that teach us how to support, collaborate, and grow together. Imagine a future where shows and films offer not just escape but frameworks for how we can solve real-life problems together, fostering empathy, cooperation, and resilience in a world that sorely needs these qualities.